Search

Stay Connected

NOAA Research News

Airborne research shows East Coast cities emitting twice as much methane as estimated
Theo Stein
/ Categories: Research Headlines, Climate

Airborne research shows East Coast cities emitting twice as much methane as estimated

Atmospheric methane is a powerful greenhouse gas that also contributes to ground-level ozone pollution. In the past decade, there has been intense scientific focus on improving the accuracy of methane emissions estimates in the United States, with most of the effort targeting oil- and natural gas-producing basins.

Now, a new NOAA and University of Michigan study using an instrumented airplane has found unexpectedly large emissions over five major cities along the East Coast - twice the total amount of methane and almost 10 times the amount estimated from natural gas. The work was published in the journal Geophysical Research Letters.

The analysis was based on airborne measurements taken from NOAA Twin Otter aircraft along the East Coast of the United States during the course of 20 research flights between April 8, 2018 to May 12, 2018, totaling 120 flight hours. The flights covered Washington, Baltimore, Philadelphia, New York, Providence and Boston, with instruments measuring levels of methane, carbon dioxide, carbon monoxide, and ethane upwind and downwind of urban areas. Methane is a primary component of natural gas.

“The amount of natural gas that flows into these older cities is very large,” said lead author Genevieve Plant, of the University of Michigan. “That means leakage from old cast-iron pipes and 'end-use' losses from inefficient appliances could be potentially be significant. We found methane emissions in the five largest cities that we sampled are significant - about double what the EPA estimates for the total emissions.”

Climate and air-quality impacts 

Quantifying methane emissions is important for assessing its current and future impact on climate and air quality. Generally there are two main sources of methane emissions from cities: methane created by the decay of organic material in landfills, and methane in releases of natural gas from old or leaky pipes, incomplete combustion from older appliances, etc.

Ethane is a component of natural gas, but is not generated by landfill, and utilities have precise measurements of how much ethane is in the gas they deliver. So it’s useful as a tracer for separating emissions coming from fossil fuel from those coming from landfills.

Image
Genevieve Plant of the University of Michigan and NOAA's Colm Sweeney review measurements of methane and other gases during an airborne research project in 2018. Credit: Eric Kort, University of Michigan

One recent synthesis study that estimated emissions from the production field all the way to the edge of cities found methane emissions were 60 percent higher than estimated by the EPA, said NOAA scientist Colm Sweeney. But that study, like most others, was not focused on examining the loss during distribution and end-use in homes and businesses.

The NOAA & UM study, by contrast, directly measured downwind plumes of emissions coming from these five cities, which included leaks from pipes and appliances. The methods used allowed scientists to quantify the total amount of methane coming from the city.  Scientists analyzed the ratio of ethane to methane to calculate how much methane was due to natural gas leakage.

A lack of data

“There’s a real lack of data on urban emissions, including end-use losses,” Sweeney said.  “In our study, we found leaks and end-use losses in just five cities was larger than what EPA estimates for leaks in the entire country. That was kind of stunning. The problem is we still do not exactly where it is coming from. Is it the pipes? Is it the appliances? What we do know is that this provides a huge opportunity for emissions reduction if we can determine the source of these leaks”

While there have been a handful of other studies of urban areas scattered around the country, this study sampled one of the largest metropolitan megaplexes, home to about 12 percent of the US population.

“It’s unclear how representative the cities we looked at are compared to other cities in the US,” Plant said. “Clearly, more work needs to be done.”

Plant said the research flights - typically at around 1,000 to 1,500 feet off the ground - made for an unusually scenic research environment. “It was quite the view,” she said. “We flew up the Hudson a few times. Flying off the coast is also quite picturesque, to say the least.”

Previous Article Robots probe ocean depths in mission to fine-tune hurricane forecasts
Next Article New NOAA app brings earth and space animations to your phone
Print
5762

x

Popular Research News

A Message from Craig McLean: Hurricane Dorian and Exceptional Service

A Message from Craig McLean: Hurricane Dorian and Exceptional Service Read more

NOAA Research Assistant Administrator Craig McLean's message to colleagues, dated Monday, September 9th, regarding Hurricane Dorian and its wide-ranging impacts

New NOAA app brings earth and space animations to your phone

New NOAA app brings earth and space animations to your phone Read more

NOAA's SOS Explorer Mobile, an app for personal mobile devices, tells earth science stories by playing visually stunning movies on a virtual globe.

Airborne research shows East Coast cities emitting twice as much methane as estimated

Airborne research shows East Coast cities emitting twice as much methane as estimated Read more

A new NOAA and University of Michigan study using an instrumented airplane has found unexpectedly large emissions over five major cities along the East Coast - twice the total amount of methane and almost 10 times the amount estimated from natural gas.

NOAA is developing underwater robots to map, measure toxicity of Great Lakes algal blooms

NOAA is developing underwater robots to map, measure toxicity of Great Lakes algal blooms Read more

Two underwater robots will be gliding throughout the western Lake Erie basin this week, as NOAA and its partners at the Monterey Bay Aquarium Research Institute (MBARI) test technology to autonomously monitor and measure the toxicity of harmful algal blooms in the Great Lakes.

NOAA seeks public input on future priorities for research and development

NOAA seeks public input on future priorities for research and development Read more

NOAA is asking the general public and our stakeholders for comments on a new draft plan that outlines agency priorities for research and development from 2020 to 2026. 

RSS
«September 2019»
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
25262728293031
1234567
891011121314
15161718192021
22232425262728
293012345

OAR HEADQUARTERS

Phone: 301-713-2458
Address: 1315 East-West Highway Silver Spring, MD 20910

Stay Connected

ABOUT US

Oceanic and Atmospheric Research (OAR) - or "NOAA Research" - provides the research foundation for understanding the complex systems that support our planet. Working in partnership with other organizational units of the NOAA, a bureau of the Department of Commerce, NOAA Research enables better forecasts, earlier warnings for natural disasters, and a greater understanding of the Earth. Our role is to provide unbiased science to better manage the environment, nationally, and globally.

CONTACT US

Can't Find What You Need?
Send Feedback
Copyright 2018 by NOAA Terms Of Use Privacy Statement
Back To Top