Saturday, February 25, 2017
 
Methane leaks from three large U.S. natural gas fields in line with federal estimates

Methane leaks from three large U.S. natural gas fields in line with federal estimates

Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences, NOAA researchers, colleagues measure lower emissions of the greenhouse gas than some other sites

Wednesday, February 18, 2015

This web story was provided by NOAA's Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences (CIRES). The CIRES story may be read online. For more information, please contact 

Katy Human, CIRES communications, kathleen.human@colorado.edu, 303-735-0196

Tens of thousands of pounds of methane leak per hour from equipment in three major natural gas basins that span Texas, Louisiana, Arkansas and Pennsylvania, according to airborne measurements published today by a NOAA-led team of scientists. But the overall leak rate from those basins is only about one percent of gas production there—lower than leak rates measured in other gas fields, and in line with federal estimates.

“We are beginning to get a sense of regional variation in methane emissions from natural gas production,” said lead author Jeff Peischl, a scientist with the Cooperative Institute for Research in Environmental Sciences (CIRES) in Boulder, Colorado. “The gas fields we studied for this paper produced about 20 percent of the natural gas in the United States, and more than half the shale gas, so this moves us closer to understanding methane leaks from U.S. natural gas production.”

Peischl works at NOAA’s Earth System Research Laboratory in Boulder, Colorado. His team’s analysis appears online today in the Journal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, published by the American Geophysical Union.

Geography of natural gas

Geography of natural gas

This map shows the shale gas "plays" or fields in the continental United States. Orange areas are current fields, red are prospective ones, and geologic basins are marked in beige. SOURCE: U.S. Energy Information Administration, www.eia.gov/oil_gas/rpd/shale_gas.jpg
In the new paper, he and his colleagues used sophisticated measurements taken from a NOAA research aircraft to determine methane emissions from the Haynesville, Fayetteville, and Marcellus regions during five flights in the summer of 2013.

Overall, they found that methane leaking from gas equipment totaled about 1.1 percent of gas produced in those regions; estimates from the Environmental Protection Agency, based on average equipment leak rates, put that figure at about 1 percent.  

Preparing for research flight

Preparing for research flight

Jeff Peischl and John Holloway check atmospheric instrument data before a research flight in the summer of 2013. The CIRES scientists and NOAA colleagues found that methane leaks from three large regions of natural gas development were in line with federal estimates, about 1 percent of production. Credit: Joost de Gouw, CIRES
“It is good news that our atmospheric measurements are close to the EPA estimates,” said co-author Joost de Gouw, a CIRES scientist who also works at NOAA. “If leak rates are too high, natural gas does not compare favorably with one alternative, coal, in terms of climate impact. Where leak rates are low, the comparison favors natural gas.”

In the new study, the researchers also reported their findings by region:

  • Methane emissions in the Marcellus region of northeastern Pennsylvania were about 16.5 tons (33,000 lbs) per hour, or 0.18-0.41 percent of production.

  • Methane emissions in the Haynesville shale of eastern Texas/northwestern Louisiana of about 88 tons (176,000 lbs) per hour, or 1.0-2.1 percent of production.

  • Methane emissions in the Fayetteville shale region of Arkansas were roughly 43 tons (86,000 lbs) per hour, or 1.0-2.8 percent of produced gas.

In other published papers, CIRES, NOAA and other researchers have found methane losses of:

The Colorado, Utah and California basins combined produce less than 3 percent of all U.S. natural gas, much less than the eastern basins.

Measuring air quality

Measuring air quality

This NOAA research aircraft was used in 2013 to fly over large segments of the U.S., to better understand air quality and climate issues. CIRES and NOAA scientists found that methane leaks from three large regions of natural gas development were in line with federal estimates, about 1 percent of production. Credit: David Oonk, CIRES
The variable methane leak rates in the different studies suggests that other chemicals emitted during gas production, including compounds that contribute to episodes of poor air quality, are also variable, de Gouw said. There could be many reasons for significant regional differences in leak rates, he added.  The composition of gas can vary across different regions, with slightly more or less methane, for example. And equipment, techniques and regulations vary, as well.

The CIRES and NOAA team is planning another aircraft mission this spring, to expand emissions measurements from gas-producing regions stretching from Texas to North Dakota. The researchers hope that, taken together, the studies will help industry identify the conditions and techniques that minimize the leaks during gas production, benefitting both the atmosphere and the industry’s bottom line.

CIRES is a partnership of NOAA and the University of Colorado Boulder.

Authors of “Quantifying atmospheric methane emissions from the Haynesville, Fayetteville, and northeastern Marcellus shale gas production regions,” are J. Peischl (CIRES/NOAA), T. B. Ryerson (NOAA),  K. C. Aikin (CIRES/NOAA), J. A. de Gouw (CIRES/NOAA), J. B. Gilman (CIRES/NOAA), J. S. Holloway (CIRES/NOAA), B. M. Lerner (CIRES/NOAA), R. Nadkarni (Texas Commission on Environmental Quality), J. A. Neuman (CIRES/NOAA), J. B. Nowak (Aerodyne Research, Inc), M. Trainer (NOAA),  C. Warneke (CIRES/NOAA), and D. D. Parrish (CIRES/NOAA).

On the web: 

  • More about the Southeast Nexus mission in the summer 2013, which explored the nexus of climate change and air quality in the U.S. Southeast. Data for this paper came from Southeast Nexus.

  • More about an upcoming mission SONGNEX, the Shale Oil and Natural Gas Nexus mission, which will expand measurements of the atmospheric impacts of oil and natural gas development, with research flights from Texas to North Dakota this spring and summer.

Download high-resolution images:

CIRES Contacts:

AGU Contact:

Research Headlines

NOAA Headlines

Connect with Research.NOAA.gov

Office of Oceanic & Atmospheric Research Headquarters

1315 East-West Highway | Silver Spring, MD 20910 | 301-713-2458